Fighting Fraud with More Fraud: The Fake Crypto Law Firm Scam

Robert Whitaker
September 2, 2025

On August 13, 2025, the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) released a new public service announcement warning about a disturbing evolution in cryptocurrency-related scams: fictitious law firms targeting scam victims themselves (IC3 PSA 250813). Criminals are now posing as attorneys, government officials, and recovery services, promising to retrieve stolen crypto while demanding upfront fees. Instead of helping, they are stealing even more.

For anyone who has lost money in a cryptocurrency scam, this is a cruel twist. Victims who are desperate for justice are now being re-victimized, often losing thousands more. The trend highlights not only the adaptability of cybercriminals but also the need for heightened awareness among investors, businesses, and law enforcement.

How Fake Law Firms Target Crypto Scam Victims

According to the most recent FBI advisory, criminals set up elaborate operations that look like legitimate legal practices. These fake firms often build convincing websites, use fabricated documents, and even steal real attorney names or bar license numbers to bolster credibility.

Once they establish contact with a victim, the fraudsters claim they can recover stolen funds. They then demand upfront payments for supposed taxes, customs fees, processing costs, or insurance. After collecting money, the scammers either vanish or invent new reasons to demand additional fees.

The victims are left not only without their original cryptocurrency but also with further losses. This cycle of re-victimization is what makes the scheme particularly devastating.

The Evolution of Recovery Scams from 2023 to 2025

The FBI has been tracking the steady growth of recovery fraud schemes for several years. Each new warning shows how the scams have become more convincing and damaging.

  • 2023 – Recovery scams begin: In August 2023, the FBI warned that fraudsters were targeting investment scam victims with false promises of recovering lost funds (IC3 PSA 230811). These criminals charged “service fees” or requested sensitive personal information, only to disappear.

  • 2024 – Government impersonators emerge: By June 2024, the scams had evolved to include criminals impersonating government officials and law enforcement officers (IC3 PSA 240624). They claimed that victims needed to pay fines or compliance costs to release seized funds.

  • 2025 – Fake law firms take the stage: The latest advisory shows how these scams have matured into full-fledged fictitious law firms, complete with websites, staff directories, and fabricated legal credentials (IC3 PSA 250813).

This evolution demonstrates the creativity and persistence of fraudsters. They continue to refine their approach, exploiting the trust people place in institutions like law firms and government agencies.

Why Cryptocurrency Victims Are Prime Targets

Victims of crypto scams are uniquely vulnerable to these schemes. Unlike credit card fraud or bank theft, cryptocurrency transactions are irreversible. Once tokens leave a wallet, there is no central authority that can reverse the transaction. This finality makes victims desperate for solutions and more willing to believe anyone who claims they can help.

Many victims also lack a clear understanding of how law enforcement investigations actually recover stolen funds. They may not realize that blockchain tracing takes time, requires official processes, and cannot guarantee full recovery. Scammers exploit this knowledge gap by presenting themselves as experts with special tools or government connections, offering a false sense of hope.

The emotional toll also plays a role. Victims often feel embarrassed, angry, or desperate. These emotions create the perfect opening for criminals who know how to promise exactly what victims want to hear: quick recovery and justice.

Common Red Flags of Fictitious Law Firm Scams

The FBI’s advisories highlight several recurring red flags that victims and businesses should watch for:

  • Unsolicited contact: Cold calls, emails, or advertisements targeting scam victims.

  • Upfront fees: Requests for payment of taxes, processing charges, customs duties, or insurance before any funds are recovered.

  • Guaranteed recovery claims: Promises that all stolen cryptocurrency can be returned, which no legitimate investigator can guarantee.

  • Pressure tactics: Urgent demands for immediate payment to avoid losing the opportunity for recovery.

  • Unverifiable credentials: Attorneys whose names or bar numbers do not match official directories, or websites with vague or plagiarized content.

  • Requests for more personal data: Demands for bank account information, private keys, or identity documents under the guise of “compliance.”

Recognizing these warning signs can prevent further victimization and stop fraudsters from collecting additional funds.

The Realities of Crypto Recovery

The FBI and other law enforcement agencies are clear: legitimate authorities will never ask for money in order to return seized funds. Recovery from crypto scams requires formal investigations, subpoenas, cooperation with exchanges, and in many cases, cross-border coordination. It is a slow and methodical process, not a quick fix.

There are legitimate companies that assist victims of cryptocurrency fraud, but their role is often misunderstood. These firms provide investigative expertise by tracing stolen assets, compiling evidence, and producing reports that can be handed to law enforcement. What they cannot do is seize funds, compel an exchange to cooperate, or guarantee recovery. Only law enforcement has the authority to take those steps. Any party claiming they can recover stolen crypto independently is simply not telling the truth.

This is where advanced blockchain analytics comes into play. Investigators use tools like Merkle Science’s Tracker to trace funds across wallets, exchanges, and even cross-chain bridges. While recovery is never guaranteed, tracing provides evidence that can lead to seizures and arrests. Unlike fictitious law firms, real investigators rely on data, evidence, and partnerships with legitimate institutions.

How Verified Digital Identity Could Disrupt These Scams

One of the most striking lessons from the rise of fictitious law firms is how easily criminals exploit digital identity gaps. Victims often cannot verify whether a supposed attorney or law firm is legitimate. In crypto, similar weaknesses exist when it comes to wallet addresses and customer onboarding.

This is where verified, blockchain-based digital identity systems could make a difference. Tamper-resistant credentials stored on-chain would give individuals and institutions a more reliable way to confirm identities. For victims, that could mean being able to immediately check whether a law firm is real. For crypto businesses, it could mean stronger defenses against fraudsters hiding behind fabricated information.

How Businesses and Victims Can Protect Themselves

For individuals:

  • Be skeptical of anyone promising to recover lost crypto, especially if they demand upfront fees.

  • Verify attorneys with state bar associations and cross-check law firm websites.

  • Never share private keys or sensitive financial details with unsolicited contacts.

  • Report suspected scams to IC3.gov.

For businesses:

  • Educate employees and customers about these evolving scams.

  • Strengthen customer-facing communication so victims know what legitimate recovery looks like.

  • Collaborate with regulators and law enforcement to share intelligence.

The Broader Lesson for Crypto and Compliance

Fictitious law firms are only the latest example of criminals exploiting hope and confusion. The underlying pattern is clear: whenever new technologies or financial systems emerge, adversaries adapt faster than protections do. Crypto is no exception.

For compliance teams, exchanges, and custodians, this means taking a proactive approach. Sanction screening, predictive risk monitoring, and robust identity verification are not optional. They are essential to prevent adversaries from turning weaknesses into profit.

Do Not Be Victimized Twice

The FBI’s August 2025 advisory should serve as a wake-up call. Criminals are not content with stealing once. They will circle back, impersonating trusted professionals to steal again. For victims of crypto scams, the most important step is to resist the urge to believe easy promises. For businesses, the responsibility is to raise awareness and help protect customers from falling into the same trap twice.

Fighting fraud with more fraud is a cruel strategy, but it is one that is working. Awareness, vigilance, and the right investigative tools are the only way to stop it.